Advantages
Encourages the creative generation of new (cogenerated) knowledge and ideas through critical discussion. Fosters collaboration ( group work ) capabilities which are highly ranked as highly employable skills. Easily matched to any HaSS discipline, but especially suited to those subjects where subjective knowledge can be critically discussed and alternative perspectives entertained.
Challenges
Some students might struggle to contribute or facilitate group discussion. Staff might encourage students to delegate tasks equitably and offer opportunities to practice during tutorials.
Tips for implementation
Staff should emphasise the collegiate value of this task to students. This will also assist to allay anxieties about public speaking.
How it supports academic integrity
Students need to actively facilitate an open discussion in real time, hence outsourcing is not possible. As the object of this exercise is to generate new ideas, any attempts to misattribute published works is also readily identifiable.