Advantages
Students are able to develop argumentative abilities (essential to HASS disciplines) in an active,
supported learning
environment. This assessment develops critical thought, improving
written
and spoken expression as well as analytic capabilities. This assessment has wide transferability to any introductory or gateway HASS courses as it teaches numerous foundational skills.
Challenges
It can be a challenge to convince high school and first year students to situate their writing confidence in the rigor and expression of their thinking rather than their use of vocabulary or grammatical accuracy – encourage prioritising structure over form.
Tips for implementation
Coordinators should strive to foster a collegiate and non-judgemental environment in which students feel enthusiastic to contribute and articulate ideas freely. Emphasising a focus on ideas over academic elocution is key to fostering this open yet supported learning environment.
How it supports academic integrity
Students are expected to discuss and develop a topic and structure their argument with peers and staff, and must complete the majority of their essay during contact hours (in dedicated class time); this mitigates against possibilities for outsourcing or plagiarism.