Advantages
This task requires that students have prepared for class (by doing the readings) and integrated the new material with previously learned content. If all students in the classroom have prepared for class, and reflected on the materials, the learning environment in the classroom is enriched. The task also encourages peer support - students build relationships with one another, assist one another to understand the content, whilst also practising their oral communication skills.
Challenges
Occasionally, students will be unable to connect with their partner to undertake the exercise (eg. where a student withdraws from the course, or is unwell or otherwise unreachable). There is no way of knowing the nature of students' discussions, or whether they are approaching the task seriously or not.
Tips for implementation
The most common problem is students losing their partner, but this is easily fixed. Even if there are odd numbers, students can be placed in a group of three (or join an existing group of 2) and have a 'teleconference'. This turns a negative into a positive as teleconferences bring unique challenges that students must then navigate. If a student is absent from class, I ask that they email me their notes (as a record of the discussion) prior to the start of class that week.