Advantages
Students can choose a site to collect their data, and design their own research question and methods, which tends to make them more engaged and invested in the assessment as they can follow their interests. Asks students to consider the connections between things happening 'in the real world' and academic discussions of issues. Physical observation of the presentation ensures that the students are who they claim to be. Teaches the students the difference between quantitative and qualitative.
Challenges
As students have typically not designed a research question, collected any data, or analysed any data before they need quite a bit of guidance. We typically devote 5-6 tutorials to in class guidance with this assessment.
Tips for implementation
Class time to guide students is highly recommended, especially if this assessment is used in first year.
How it supports academic integrity
Physical observation of the presentation ensures that the students are who they claim to be.